Cast from Stalked by My Amish Boyfriend

Leigha Sinnott

Carly

Sam Bullington

Abram

Courtney Grace

Jenna

John Castle

Grant

Samantha Binkerd

Mona

Nick Clark

Wyatt

Annette Saunders

Martha

Hailey Swartwout

Sarah

Diane Kirby

Officer Johnson

Zoe Wiesner

Rachel

Micah Sanders Silva

Isaiah

Matthew Ellsworth

Preacher