Cast from The Wrong Guy

Dave Foley

Nelson Hibbert

David Anthony Higgins

Det. Arlen

Jennifer Tilly

Lynn Holden

Joe Flaherty

Fred Holden

Dan Redican

Ken Daly

Alan Scarfe

Farmer Brown

Kenneth Welsh

Mr. Nagel

Enrico Colantoni

Creepy Guy

Colm Feore

The Killer

Arnie Achtman

Bus Station Worker

Boyd Banks

Gas Station Guy

Johanna Nicosia

Cindy

Valerie Boyce

Manicurist

Alan Bridle

Juddidah

Dana Brooks

Nagel's Secretary

Steven Page

Policeman #1

Tyler Stewart

Policeman #2

Ed Robertson

Policeman #3

Kevin McDonald

Motel Manager

Mark McKinney

Cameo (uncredited)

Ralph Small

Guard reviewing security footage