Cast from Sabrina the Teenage Witch

Melissa Joan Hart

Sabrina Sawyer

Sherry Miller

Aunt Hilda

Charlene Fernetz

Aunt Zelda

Michelle Beaudoin

Marnie Littlefield

Ryan Reynolds

Seth

Tobias Mehler

Harvey

Lalainia Lindbjerg

Katy Lemore

Laura Harris

Freddie

Kea Wong

Fran

Jo Bates

Coach

Janine Cox

Sales Clerk

Biski Gugushe

Larry

Tyler Labine

Mark

Jim Swansburg

Mr. Dingle

Noel Geer

Jeff

Volton

D.J.

Cory Chetyrbok

Student (uncredited)

Kevin Corey

Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Nick Bakay

Salem (voice)