Cast from The Gilgo Beach Murders

Jennifer Polansky

Tina Everett

Adam Ginsberg

The Killer

Dewey Wynn

Mark

Renee Kay

Sheryl Graham

Ryan Kaiser

Jimmy

Lindsay DeLuca

Elizabeth Stark

Matthew Smolko

Rick

Josephine Pizzino

Jane Everett

Stav Livne

Sarah Coleman

Joe Mankowski

Benjamin Harvey

Guy Balotine

Jude

Chrissy Laboy

Michelle Coleman

Sara Antkowiak

Colette

Patrick Devaney

Detective Kaplan

Jeff Solomon

Tyler

Samantha Rivers Cole

Diamond

Dan Capalbo

The Professor

Keith McMahon

Desk Sergeant

Jill di Donato

Victim #1

Kelly Rae LeGault

Interviewed Prostitute

Richard Maris

Strip Club Owner

William Rubel

The Vagrant

Bethany Geraghty

News Reporter

Heather Drew

Victim #3

Dave Campfield

Maitre D (voice)

Scott Croce

Club Patron

Michael Eimicke

Club Patron

Elsie Martinez Ginsberg

News Anchorwoman (voice)

William Hellfire

Club Patron

Mike Hunchback

Club Patron

Marieta Morchadze

Dancer in Strip Club

Elizabeth Napier

Dancer in Strip Club

Toni Ortiz

Girl in Strip Club

Lance Roberti

Club Patron

Howard Simon

Club Patron / The Professor's Colleague