Cast from Amish Witches: The True Story of Holmes County

Nicole Rodenburg

Conor

Hayley Palmaer

Esther

Kaylyn Scardefield

Iva

Evangeline Young

Ruthie

Michelle Young

Katie Ann

Caleb Carlson

Isaac

Troy Curtis

Dave

Chase Conner

Will

Amanda Jane Stern

A.J.

David Winning

The Bishop

Mieke Stapelberg

Soloma

Clare Buckingham

Abigail

Andrea Demarco

Deceased Grandmother

Luke Tourtelliotte

Baby

Asia Manuel

Diner Waitress

Clayton Brown

Police Officer #1

Antoine Smith

Police Officer #2

Derek Roberts

EMT #1

Montgomery Lyons

EMT #2

Casey Quake

EMT #3

Josh G. Allegra

Horse and Buggy Driver

Randy Franklin

Footman

Natalie Vogel

Amish Market Mother

Neil Rosen

Amish Market Son

Leila Godbot

Amish Market Daughter

Jaret J. Lennett

Amish Market Man

Melissa Lopez

Diner Patron Couple

Zachary Woodstock

Diner Patron Couple

Ryan Barto

Diner Patron Teen #1

Adrianna Dellavalle

Diner Patron Teen #2

Anne Supina

Diner Patron Teen #3

Alex Cerdeira

Diner Patron Family

Ashlyn White

Diner Patron Family