Cast from The Bachelor Next Door

Haylie Duff

Alex

Michael Welch

Donnie

Brittany Underwood

Sage

Tyler Johnson

Johnny

Sarah Davenport

Allison

Caia Coley

Kaya

Preeti Desai

Jennifer Green

Kim Estes

Detective

Steven Bruns

Gavin

Blaise Brooks

Receptionist

David Hill

Police Officer