Cast from Moonlight & Mistletoe

Tom Arnold

Nick

Candace Cameron Bure

Holly

Christopher Wiehl

Peter

Barbara Niven

Ginny

Matt Walton

Ben Richards

Allan F. Nicholls

Earl

Kaily Smith Westbrook

Brenda

Heather Remick

Della

Bruce Bouchard

Mr. Covell

Richard Waterhouse

Mr. Jennings

Taylor Ampatiellos

Willy

Lillian Pritchard

Young Holly

Ari Larson

Young Peter

Parma

Nick's Dog

Gary Boyles

Office worker (uncredited)

Dave Kulvete

Elf waiter (uncredited)

Emily George Lyons

Willy's Mom (uncredited)

R.W. Martin

Townsperson (uncredited)