Cast from Am I a Serial Killer?

Monroe Cline

Natalie

Jhey Castles

Caroline

Crystal Allen

Annie

Andrew Lauer

Dr. Welk

Angela Nicholas

Captain Lawrence

Brady Richards

Geoff

Jordan Leer

Kent

Charles Christopher

Owen

James C. Burns

John Matthews

McKinley Blehm

Young Natalie

Jesus Ruiz

Bill Titcher

Tara Malenfant

Lisa Collins

Tom Gurnee

Principal

Gayla Johnson

Prison guard

Gar-Ye Lee

Medical examiner

Hank Grover

Reporter