Cast from First Date

Tyson Brown

Mike

Shelby Duclos

Kelsey

Jesse Janzen

The Captain

Nicole Berry

Sergeant Davis

Ryan Quinn Adams

Vince

Brandon Kraus

Chet

Angela Barber

Ricky

Dave Reimer

Shannon

Samuel Ademola

Deputy Duchovny

Scott E. Noble

Dennis

Leah Finity

Darla

Shari Schweigler

Thelma

Graham Green

Roger

Samantha Laurenti

Mikaylah

Todd Goble

Tony

Josh Fesler

Brett