Cast from The Candlenights 2021 Special

Justin McElroy

Self / Taako Taaco / Chris Evergreen

Travis McElroy

Self / Magnus Burnsides / Jingle King

Griffin McElroy

Self / Angus McDonald / Business Person

Sydnee McElroy

Self / Tabitha Bigcity

Clint McElroy

Santa / Merle Highchurch

Teylor Smirl

Self / Flatwoods Monster / Tabitha's Sibling

Rileigh Smirl

Self

Rachel McElroy

Self

Tommy Smirl

Self

Teresa McElroy

Self / Girlboss

B. Dave Walters

Self

Hank Green

Self

Jean Grae

Self

Paul Sabourin

Self

Storm DiCostanzo

Self

Adam Brody

Self

Satine Phoenix

Self

Brennan Lee Mulligan

Self

Carol McElroy

Mrs. Claus

Ashly Burch

Self

Alex Horne

Self

Jonathan Coulton

Self

Russ Frushstick

Self

Tim Batt

Self

Guy Montgomery

Self

Dan Goubert

Cap'n Crunch

Chris Plante

Self

Steve Williams

Self

Dwight Slappe

Happy Customer

Amanda Coleman

Self

Mary Smirl

Self

Charlie McElroy

Intern

Cooper McElroy

Intern

Aparna Nancherla

Self