Daisy Danby
Older Elliott
Kelly Peters
Greek Council President (voice)
Depressed Debbie
Darius Britt
Jeanine Breemer
Olivia
Marnie
Brandy Klark
Woman
Beth Slocum
Sarah
Mallory
Jean
Wow Platinum
Susan Weber
Kelly
Grumpy Cat / Self (voice)
Lenore
Woman in Park
Jen
Self
Aubrey Plaza
Chelsi
The Jinn
April Ludgate
Cassie Stickle
Aubrey
Girl
Tatiana
Herself
Self - Julie Powers
Ingrid Thorburn
Sister Fernanda
Lulu Danger
Ashley
Monika Nark
Brain (voice)
Karen Barclay
Julie
Rose
Allison
Riley Johnson
Lucy Stanbridge
Girl on subway
Julie Powers
Sarah Fidel
Kat
Pine Cone (voice)
Emily
Lucy (voice) (uncredited)
Dr. Rachel Wheating (voice)
Page
Laura Feinberg (voice)
Aaron Burr
Robin
Julie Powers (voice)
Self - Host
Cat Adams
Lenny Busker
Beth
Bookstore Customer
The Princess
Hawaiian Coffee
Nina (voice)
Lindsay
Self - Guest Judge
Harper Spiller
Self - Guest
Mary Wollstonecraft
Rio Vidal
Amber (voice)
Claire (voice)
Bernadette
The Rememberer
Dylan Beekler
Nocturna (voice)
Olga Acevedo
Stephanie
(voice)
Sacagawea
Eska