Anthony Swofford
Donnie Darko
Jack Twist
Sam Hall
Danny Robbins
Robert Graysmith
Douglas Freeman
Joe Nast
John Prophet
Master Sergeant John Kinley
Prince Dastan
Harold 'Hal' Dobbs
Holden Worther
Jimmy Livingston
Homer Hickam
Dalton
Jamie Randall
Self
Colter Stevens
Pilot Kelson
Jordan
Brian Taylor
Detective Loki
Adam / Anthony
Scott Fischer
Self (archive footage)
Searcher Clade (voice)
Louis Bloom
Tommy Cahill
Davis Mitchell
Billy 'The Great' Hope
Howard Birdwell
Frank O'Connor (archive footage)
Edward Sheffield / Tony Hastings
Jake Gyllenhaal
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
Elwood Dalton
Dr. Johnny Wilcox
Dr. David Jordan
Jeff Bauman
Robert Evans
Iago
Jerry Brinson
Self / Joe Nast
Donnie Darko / Anthony Swafford (archive footage)
John Morris
Morf Vandewalt
Edward
Jake
Leon Coleman
Narrator (voice)
The Damned
Quentin Beck / Mysterio
Joe Baylor
Self (uncredited)
Mr. Music
Self - Performer
Danny Sharp
Jim Prescott (voice)
Nathan Cole
Self - Guest
Matt Ellison
Self - Host
Self - Cameo (uncredited)
Self - Nominee
Rozat 'Rusty' Sabich