Clara Clayton
Maggie Clarke
Karen Buckman
Betty Carver
Emily
Sarah Davis
Carol
Stella Keefover
Hannah Nixon
Rosemary Sydney
Joanie Fisher
Sally Rider
Amy Robbins
Adrian
Nancy Huff
Marilyn
Mother
Narrator (voice)
Jessie Caldwell
Julia Tate
Ginny Grainger
Beverley, Leah's Mother
Bootsie Robicheaux
Mrs. Kimball
Café Patron
Sarah Michaelson
Gayle
Lynda Dummar
Dr. Blaine
Sister Ida
Estelle
Grace Paxton
Young Sarah
Rose Pickett
Geneva Leigh
Katherine Bellamy
Mrs. Parker (Mother)
Peggy
Julie Rose / Katie McGovern / Evelyn
Mother (voice)
Marienne Hotchkiss
Self
Detective Karen Condrin
Francine Pinkney
Phoebe Craddock
Anastasia Lee
Helen West
Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings
Diana Boyle
Mother (archive footage)
Sarah Elizabeth McCaffrey
Karen Ellis
Elaine Rutledge
Belinda Conine
Louisa Poole
Emma Wheeler
Colleen Beck
Aunt Cly
Miep Gies
Julia Mureaux
Jeannie
Mrs. Yankovic
Katherine
Cybil Burger
Elaine Stein
Maybelle
Little Red Riding Hood a.k.a. Mary
Visitor #2
Dr. Blake
Interviewer
Amanda Winship
Dr. Margot
Gloria
Flannery O'Connor (voice)
Tipper
Mom (voice)
Reader (voice)
Mary Steenburgen
Kate Montgomery
Self (uncredited)
Self - Guest
Helen Girardi
Grace Rinato
Marjorie (voice)
Patient (uncredited)
Mary / Little Red Riding Hood
Clara Clayton (voice)
Delia Powell
Catherine Newman
Crystalynn (voice)
Self - Presenter
Gail Klosterman
Diana Jessup
Nicole Warren Diver
Adriana
Katherine Hale
Mary Gulliver
Naamah
Narrator (Voice)
Audrey Veill
Marcy Bellinger
Ellen Joy Bonar
Linda
Teacher
Miriam