Jim Taylor
Pawnee Bill
(in "Johnny Eager") (archive footage)
D.B. Norton
Anthony P. Kirby
Joe Lorgan
Paul Atlas
Penrod Biddel
Big Bill Barton
Self (archive footage)
John Benson Farrell
Daniel Webster
Oliver Tubbs
Paul Madvig
Ace
Emperor Valerius
Lawyer (segment "Pay the Two Dollars")
The Grand Vizier
Achille Weber
Jack Brennan
Inspector Porfiry
Det. Lt. 'Mac' MacCarthy
Robert Cain Sr.
Amory Stilham
Jim Fisk
J.B. Ball
Duke Morgan
Sam Harper
Richard M. Gresham
Duncan 'Mac' Maclain
Danny Harrison
Barney Glasgow
Merrill Lambert
Martin Edley
Judson M. 'J.M.' / 'Judsy' Blair
T.T. Ralston
Capt. Duncan Maclain
Elliot Fulton
David 'Dave' Lash
Lt. Lorrgan
Martin Creavy
Hobart Canford Stiles
Sidney Parker
Seymour Purchwell
Judge Wilkins
Judge Harry Wilkins
Mike Glenson
Burton V. Lyons
Vincent Cushing
Robert Nelson
Quentin 'Doc' Ramsey
Commissioner Forster
James 'Jim' Cork
Mr. 'Feydie' Feydak
Father Saracinesca
Mr. Charles G. Bledsoe
Senator Wilkins
Nero Wolfe
Diamond Jim Brady
Jake Dillon
Andrew J. Linnett
Sen. Brander
Jim Knox
Mahoney
Ira Collins
The Range (voice)
Charles Conway
Ray Phillips
T.J. Todd
Theodore Findley
Judge Martin O. Abercrombie
The Devil
John Meade
Sir John Arlington
Achmed Pasha
Johan (John) Sutter
Jim Cain
Doctor Remezov
Louis XIII
Diamond Jim
Sen. James McKinley
Diamond Jim Brady (edited from 'Diamond Jim')
(uncredited)
Inspector Ennis
Secretary of War Wardell
Congressman Arthur Malcolm
Vincent Shelton
(archive footage) (uncredited)
Martin 'Stuff' Nelson
Adm. Homer Thorndyke
Moriarty Henchman In Striped Cap
Politician (uncredited)
Juror #10
The Mayor of New York
Ambassador William Fisk
Schultz
Self
Jig Skelli
Frank Rodie
Tom Wentworth
Orson Bitzer
J.R. Compton
Mr. Frewen
Self - Guest Host
Jock Fathian
John Prescott / Mayor Underwood
Lieutenant Shipley
Self - Mystery Guest