Harry Tuttle
Travis Bickle
Al Capone
Louis Gara
John 'Johnny Boy' Civello
Vito Corleone
Rupert Pupkin
David 'Noodles' Aaronson
Neil McCauley
Sam 'Ace' Rothstein
Bill Sullivan
Conrad Brean
Louis Cyphre
Jake LaMotta
Lt. Moe Tilden
Jack Byrnes
Lorenzo Anello
Max Cady
James Conway
The Creature / Sharp Featured Man
Father Bobby
Captain Shakespeare
Don Lino (voice)
Self
Alfredo Berlinghieri
Eddie Flemming
Wayne "Mad Dog" Dobie
Donald Rimgale
Leonard Lowe
Richard Wells
David Callaway
Danny
Nick Wells
Ned
Rodrigo Mendoza
Det. Mitch Preston
David Merrill
Michael Vronsky
Walt Koontz
Lloyd Barker
Self (archive footage)
Senator John McLaughlin
Dwight Hansen
Sam
Master Chief Leslie W. Sunday ('Billy')
Father Des Spellacy
Ben
Prisoner / Lustig
Jack Walsh
Paul Vitti
Gil Renard
Jimmy Doyle
Young Vito Corleone
Wallace "Wally" Carter
Frank Goode
Detective Tom 'Turk' Cowan
Mardigian
Vincent LaMarca
Stanley Everett Cox
Harry Fabian
Bruce Pearson
Jon Rubin
Great Sewer (voice)
Stan Harris
Monroe Stahr
Jack
Archbishop of Peru
Billy 'The Kid' McDonnen
Joseph 'Jacknife' Megessey
Hunter
Fearless Leader
Carl Van Loon
Frank Raftis
Evan M. Wright
Pat Solatano Sr.
Cecil
Self - Actor
Simon Silver
Adrian
(archive footage)
The Husband of The Star-Fantasy on a Cruise
Benjamin Ford
Jonathan Flynn
Mario
Don Griffin
Self - Narrator (voice)
Sarcone
Self (uncredited) (archive footage)
Fred Blake / Giovanni Manzoni
Patrick 'Paddy' Connors
Ray Arcel
Self - Portrait Subject (archive footage)
Stan Bernal
Emmanuel Ashburn
Dragna
Ben Whitaker
Victor Tellegio (uncredited)
G.B.
Vito Genovese / Frank Costello
Dick Kelly
Ted Delaney
Sam Nicoletti
Self - Archive Footage
Rudy
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)
The Pope
Self - Speaker
Bernie Madoff
Robert De Niro
Jackie Burke
Neil McCauley (archive footage)
Frank Sheeran
Jon Rubin (archive footage)
Ed
Client at the Diner (uncredited)
King (voice)
Self (uncredited)
Murray Franklin
Un hippie chez Popov (uncredited)
William Hale
Host
Self - Reader - Declaration of Independence
Max Barber
Sheriff Church
James
General Gil Dillenbeck
Salvo Maniscalco
Sam Nicoletti (archive footage)
Video footage
Self - Host
Self - Cameo (uncredited)
Vincent
Self - Nominee
Self - Guest
Lui-même (Archive)
George Mullen
Boss
Weatherman