Bar Guy #2
Jeb Bush
Reindeer / Sergeant (voice)
Randy
Will Rollins
Martin Brockett
Peter
Paul Fletcher
The Man
Otis
Michael
Lionel Travitz
Eric Genson
Jonathan
Mick Leary
Sean Hickey
Jason Ritter
Clancy Whitfield
Frank Cleary Jr.
Jason
Ben Dwellman
Tim
Wally
Mike
Bruce
Owen
Receptionist
Kurt
Damien
Kid Loco
Alex
Wil
Garret
Jacob
Matt
Fritz
Guy
Orion
Jeff
Jeff Fredrick
Jack Malloy
Usher
Julian
Various (voice) (archive sound)
Bill Hart
Bill
Self
Ryder (voice)
Harry
Jack
Little Acorn (voice)
Carl
Dipper Pines (voice) (archive footage)
Self (archive footage)
Yoni
Baby in a Stroller (uncredited)
Dipper Pines (voice)
Ethan Haas
Kevin Girardi
Billy Baker
Self - Guest
Mark Cyr
Deputy Denny Reese
Clicker (uncredited)
Josh
Barrel (voice)
Sean Walker
Gavin
Simon Lee
Frederick Bellacourt
Elisha Gray
Self - Presenter
Robert Wilson
Cpt. Jonathan Fall (voice)
Kevin
Mr. Fisk (voice)
Self - Panelist
Nick Simms
Skipper (voice)
Pat
Eric
Buddy Griffin
(voice)
Stetson Kennedy
Art Heist Investigator