Young Nat's Father
Morris Bernstein / Barker
Father Lucci
Uncle Harold
Larry
Peter Dunning
Stephen, Alice's Husband
Graham Knox
Lt. Gold
Attorney General Brown
California Man
Scoop Rosenbaum
Carmine Monopoli
Banks' Partner #1
Charles
Robert Portman
Peter Hofstrom
Dr. Ryan Pierce
Louis
Robert
Tateh
Dallen Parcel
Lanny Davis
Alan
Richard Emery
Mr. Grosch
John Jewell
Emergency Room Doctor
Mr. Cohen
Tateh (segment "Ragtime") (archive footage)
Scoop Rosenbaum (segment "The Heidi Chronicles")
'Papa' Leplée / American Sailor
Ben Cohen
Sam Giancana
Father William
Goldman
Alan Burke
Arthur Wexler
Kohn
Steve Burris
Damon
Crocodile / Banana (voice)
District Attorney
George Silver
Nolan Farber
George
Lawrence Szilard
Lead Mop (voice)
Andre the Artist (voice)
Pa (voice)
Additional Muppets (voice)
William Goodwin
Defense Attorney Harold Jensen
Harry
Self
Al Vekovius
Frank Vernon
Morgan
Henry Sohn