David Marshall
Jonathan
Mason
Jim Whittman
Stewart
Tony Contiella
Box Saunders
Fred Searing
Eric Keppler
Kurt Buckman
Mitch Wilson
Fake Batman (segment "Super Hero Speed Dating")
Bomba (voice)
David Clark
Gene Dentler
Andrew McDonnell
Self / Vance / Pete Twinkle
Chester
Self
Jake Harper
Mike McKinney
Two A-Holes
Red (voice)
Larry Snyder
Various (archive footage)
Cop #1
Henry Herschel
Bradley
Hitpig (voice)
Glenn
Oscar
Dave Johnson
Matt Ryder
Nacho Fan
Jim Hoffman
Justin Pin / Ares (voice)
Principal Brown
Lex Tanner
Himself
Jimmy Ray
Red
Self (archive footage)
Tommy Danes
Felcher
Self - Various Characters
Floyd DeBarber
Self - Winner
Jason Sudeikis (voice)
Self - Guest
Various
Holt Richter (voice)
Dr. Robert 'Bobby' Fiscus
Schmitty
Bryce (voice)
Self - Host
Zorn (voice)
Mike Miller
Carter Grant
Kim
Aliki
Self / Host
Shane Gerald / Cole Gerald
Shane Gerald
Cole Gerald
Self - Judge
Self - Cameo (uncredited)
Thomas Edison
Ted Lasso
Bike Scout Trooper #1
Self - Contestant