Carrie Brownstein
Weird Al Yankovic
Self
George Newman
Self - Singer, Songwriter, Accordionist
Self (archive footage)
'Weird Al'
himself
Giles Standish
Himself
Waiter
Vic Vankoh (voice)
Jesus
Melvin Baldron
Tony Scotti
Self - Performer
self
Barton Mathis / Dollmaker (voice)
'Weird Al' Yankovic (voice)
Rubberduck (voice)
Producer
Hammerleg Lead Singer
'Weird Al' Yankovic
Nerd
Uncle Muscles (as Al Yankovic)
"You pigs...say your prayers."
Gentleman Ghost / Darkseid (voice)
Cameo - Himself
Weird Al
Self (Archive Footage)
Shirt Cannon Guy (voice)
Guy Playing Accordion (uncredited)
Narrator
Self / Phineas Gage
The Riddler (voice)
"Weird Al" Yankovic
Wizard Evil Blue Barf Bag
Cabbage Man
Uncle Muscles
Lindsay The Vampire
Self - Judge
Lewis / Additional Voices (voice)
Singing Minstrel (voice)
Squid Hat
Steve
(voice)
Mike Cankers
Animal Man (voice)
Al the Ringmaster
Dr. Screwball Jones (voice)
Probabilitor the Annoying (voice)
Preston (voice)
Self - Co-Host
"Weird Al" Yankovic (voice)
Milo Murphy (voice)
Weird / Al (voice)
Mr. Sun
Mr. Ding-a-Ling (voice)
Shapeshifter (voice)
Jasper (voice)
Simon
Young Michael
Wawa Weasel (voice)
Introducer
Litter Critter (voice)
Petroleum Joe (voice)
Title Card Reader (voice)
Wacko Wally (voice)
Himself (voice)
Polka Sven (voice)
Self - Guest
Tug Friendly
Al yankovic/kevin
Al yankovic/kaiju
Self - Panelist
Cheese Sandwich (voice)
Captain Peanutbutter (voice)
Dandruff Tuba (voice)
Wreck-Gar (voice)
Guest
Weird Pal (voice)
Adolf Hitler
Isaac Newton
Banana Man
Darkseid (voice)
Jackie Brazen
4-LOM (voice)
Mayor Van Helsing (voice)