Humkin
Alan
Jeffrey Price
John Keathley
Arthur Ingram
Shane Murphy
Michael Chernus
Self (archive footage)
Freddie
Brian Colby
Mr. Dimming
Turboschmuck
Kenny
Michael Watts
Paul
Dylan
Gary
Roy
Clyde Goodwin Jr.
Dylan Heinz
Jon Garth Murray
Phineas Mason / Tinkerer
Ben
Ned
Jaimie
Male Nurse
Mal
Grant Spinelli
Kirby
Actor #3 / Twentysomething #1
Jerry
Bus Driver
Michael
Trofimov
Doug
David
Pete Anderton
Cal Chapman
Edwin Borstein
Louis "Fritz" Fedowitz
Edward Tavner
Spencer Harman
New Jersey Bar Owner
Pastor Rick
Ryan Flanagan
Tommy Sullivan
Kyle
Ricken Hale
Jay Delaney
Tommy
Eric (voice)
Everly Pirdoo
Dr Paul Wimsimer
Ken Rosey
Tom
John Wayne Gacy
Francis Hamm