Dick Pepperfield
Mayor Brown
Mitchell (voice)
Christian Holloway
Mr. Doobin
Anchor Aaron Campbell
Self
Lance (voice)
Marty Allison
Bill
The Voice of Busey
Isaiah Lamb
Neighbor
Warren
Classmate
Lloyd Hastings
Officer Keys (voice)
Don Davis
Radio Announcer (voice)
Marty Denman
Steve
Husband
Mailroom Worker
Curtis
Scott
Luke Pfaffler
Mr. Fuller
Dr. Todd
Principal Dwight
Nani's Dad (voice)
Lucan / 'Right On' Glutton / Jim Jones / Airport Screener / Ulysses' Naysayer (voice)
Mike Mercer
(voice)
Cameroon
Murgetroid (voice)
Movie Goer
Payroll Guy
Uncle Mike (voice)
Father McDuffy
Various
Terrence Cutler
Old Man (voice)
Brad
Mr. Peckem
Charlton Wimbledon
Ron Dennison (voice)
Young Luther (voice)
Tom Hilgendorf
Danny Mahoney
Don Dimello
Chip Gardner
Clark "Murph" Murphy/Deputy Anton/Old Fella /Local Yokel (voice)
SWAT Member #3 (voice)
Forrest MacNeil
Dennis Taylor
Bryce Grieke
J.R. Scheimpough (voice)
Memphis Stormfront / Uber Driver (voice)
Memphis Stormfront / Snoopaloompa (voice)
Artie Mann
Andy Daly
Richard Tracy
Two Face / Astronaut (voice)
Kheirosiphon / Wyatt (voice)
Scarm Scarmely (voice)
Kheirosiphon / Popcop (voice)
Doctor
Samuel (voice)
Ranger Carl (voice)
Q.R. Dunlop (voice)
Auctioneer (voice)
Manager (voice)
Ray (voice)
Dr. Richard Price
Obo (voice)
Dale
Ethan Coque
Principal Brown
Blake (voice)
Two-Face (voice)
Dave Katterttrune
Thom Hinkle
The President / Darryl / Mister Miracle (voice)
Two-Face / Mr. Covington (voice)
Two-Face / High Owl (voice)
Two-Face / Dent (voice)
Ethan Cocque
Dr. Evan Windsor
Nathan
Andy the Watchdog (voice)
Mulligan / Server (voice)
Darryl (voice)
Accident Victim (voice)
Wallpaper Man / Politician Dude / Delivery Guy / Kid #2 (voice)
Keith Quinn
Cheesecake (voice)
Pete (voice)
Park Employee (voice)
Judge (voice)
Jeffrey Bouché
Joseph of Arimathea (voice)
Security (voice)
Kevin (voice)
Judge Dowd (voice)
Teddy Roosevelt
Frank
Chipotle Guy
Rodney Spratz
Host
Dr. Wendy Engle / Motel Pillow #1 (voice)
Ghost of Harry Houdini (voice)
Dr. Wendy Engle (voice)
Krombopulos Michael (voice)
Ben Franklin / Gordon
Norway Ambassador
Two-Face / The President (voice)
Memphis Stormfront (voice)
Darryl / Worker 1 (voice)
Waiter (voice)
Toy Man / Darryl (voice)
Cheescake (voice)
Fities Narrator (voice)