Paul Scheer

Paul / Various

Rob Huebel

Rob / Various

Aziz Ansari

Aziz / Various

Matt Walsh

Sugar Plums Agent

Brian Posehn

Various

H. Jon Benjamin

Jeff Donovan

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Mindy

Bill Hader

Little Kevin

Alison Becker

Andy Blitz

Tony Woliner

Rob Riggle

Barry

Rob Lathan

Movie Producer

Jon Glaser

Devil

June Diane Raphael

Casting Director

Tracy Morgan

The Invisible Man (voice)

Fred Armisen

Dr. Marker

Casey Wilson

Young Mom

Linda Cardellini

Melody Richards

Kristen Schaal

Girl in Doritos Commercial

David Cross

Peter Burns

A.D. Miles

CrimeTime Reenactor

Andy Samberg

Jonathan

Patton Oswalt

Let's Go Fan

Atticus Shaffer

Wade Richards (uncredited)

Ghostface Killah

Self

Paul Iacono

Billy Boy

Nick Swardson

Rob's Agent

Jonah Hill

Weenie King Customer

Michael Delaney

NYU Professor

Jay Johnston

Whale Trainer

Nichole Hiltz

Tina

Jackie Clarke

Shelia

Adam Farabee

Reggie

Kristen Ruhlin

Lemonade Girl

Anthony Del Negro

Jack / Lemonade Boy (uncredited)

Will Blagrove

Streetballer

David Foy

Austin Powers Impersonator

Alexandra Gizela

News Reporter

Kenneth Keith Kallenbach

Tom Cruise Impersonator

Susan Lay

Miriam

Angela Muto

Crack Head

Miriam Tolan

Susan

Girstin Bergquist

Waitress / Party Guest (uncredited)

Brandon Johnson

CrimeTime Reenactor